(This is ALL my imagination) After a crushing defeat by GingerBrave’s team, the "little genius" Strawberry Crepe Cookie failed to escape and was taken prisoner. YOUR STRAWBERRY CREPE COOKIE!

Black Sapphire Cookie got lost and stopped being the voice/sidekick—or whatever you want to call him—until he finds his master and "sis." He was eventually found by the Ancient Heroes. Sapphire's role was that of a master rumormonger who spread malicious gossip to turn the public against the Ancient Heroes, aiding his master, Shadow Milk Cookie, in a larger scheme of deceit.

They're gone?... BLACK SAPPHIRE COOKIE SNAP!

A woman named Ali is trying to take Miss Circle's place. You, as a student, need to uncover the truth before the impostor dresses up as Miss Circle to imitate her. (Should I have one of you play Miss Circle and the other play someone trying to replace Miss Bloomie and Miss Thavel?)

Okay, you can be... well, anyone! Zip, Abbie, or Engel. Zip's mother dated Abbie's dad, then moved on to Engel's dad. Now Zip's siblings are Chip, Abbie, and Engel.

Well, well — look what we’ve got! Black Sapphire Cookie unconscious and suffering memory loss? And GingerBrave and his team found him out in the woods! What happens next? (You can be whoever you want 🤪)

You are Strawberry Crepe Cookie on GingerBrave's team, with a pick-me who has a crush on CCI (Strawberry Crepe Cookie x Custard Cookie III)

Save or kill? You can be anyone—or be Strawberry Crepe Cookie. Strawberry Crepe Cookie has been captured, and GingerBrave and his team are being threatened. If they don't obey, Strawberry Crepe Cookie is going to die.

OH! WELL! Shadow Milk Cookie was caught by the Pure Vanilla Kingdom!

Why am i always shiping? Anyways here is..HUSK X ALASTOR!!! And you can be husk or Alastor

Yes, it sounds exactly like the title, but this school only lasts for 10 weeks. Okay, you're Alice—tough luck. (Just try not to leave the school and run into Miss Grace's arms like the picture shows)

A new, powerful being — a long-forgotten Archfiend — ambushes the Ancient Heroes. They manage to seal Hollyberry Cookie inside a fortress to neutralize the power of light and foundational magic. (This is Black Sapphire Cookie x Sliverbell Cookie)

You are SMC! (Shadow Milk Cookie!)

Okay! Greetings, folks! The Ancient Heroes took down (killed) Shadow Milk Cookie! Now they're pretending to be Shadow Milk Cookie to give orders to Black Sapphire Cookie and Candy Apple Cookie!

You're me!? Take care of my OCs!

So, I couldn't pick an OC timeline, so they're all together.